84-year-old housing benefit claimant wins £14,550 overpayments appeal

16 June 2022

Lily Lewis

An 84-year-old pensioner with multiple vulnerabilities, has won her appeal against having to repay her local council almost £15,000 which it had made in overpayments to her.

The Council said that she needed to pay £14,550 for Housing Benefit payments made between 2013 and 2019. She appealed to the First-Tier Tribunal (Social Entitlement).

The overpayment had occurred because increases to one of the appellant’s pensions had not been taken into account when her Housing Benefit had been calculated by the Council. The Council argued that the payments were recoverable on the basis that she should have informed them of any changes to her pension.

The appellant, represented pro bono by Lily Lewis from our housing team, successfully argued that the Council’s failure to seek relevant information about her pension income amounted to an official error. Her appeal was allowed and the overpayment was found by the Tribunal not to be recoverable. Lily Lewis represented the appellant in this case pro bono through We Are Advocate.

Lily Lewis has a multidisciplinary practice encompassing housing, homelessness and social security lawpublic law and inquests and public inquiries.

Chambers news

Chambers news

Garden Court North stands in solidarity with victims and families of Manchester Arena bombing on eighth anniversary

Tributes are laid for the 22 victims of the Manchester Arena bombing at Manchester Victoria Station, following a minute’s silence on 22 May 2025. Credit:...

Chambers news

Professor Javaid Rehman’s findings endorsed in US House of Representatives’ resolution on Iran

Professor Javaid Rehman (pictured) addresses the UN Human Rights Council as Special Rapporteur on 22 November 2022. Credit: UN Human Rights Council / YouTube.  ...

Chambers news

“Lack of candour” prevalent following deaths at NHS mental health trusts in Essex, Lampard Inquiry hears

Garden Court North’s Anna Morris KC and Lily Lewis represent INQUEST, whose Director Deborah Coles (pictured) gave evidence to the Lampard Inquiry on 12 May...

Chambers news

Court of Appeal hearing begins on equality of welfare access for EU citizens with pre-settled status

Garden Court North’s Tom Royston (pictured, middle) is representing the3million at the hearing in the Court of Appeal, London. Credit: the3million.   Yesterday (14 May...

Sign up to our mailing list

Our mailing list is dedicated to professionals with an interest in our work.

Sign up