JR elicits clarification of Section 25 of the Magistrates Courts Act 1980

7 March 2006

Judicial Review proceedings brought against Manchester City Youth Court yesterday were successful in challenging the Youth Court’s decision to decline jurisdiction to deal with trial and sentence. Clarification of this procedure under Section 25 was then given.

R (on the application of R) v Manchester City Youth Court [2006] EWHC 564 (Admin)  is one of a long line of cases challenging decisions of Youth Courts to decline jurisdiction and commit for trial where there was no realistic prospect of the defendant being given a sentence in excess of 2 years detention (see Section 24 of the Magistrates Courts Act 1980).

The Claimant, R, aged 15 and of previous good character, was charged with an unremarkable burglary. Ouseley J quashed the decisions to refuse jurisdiction and to commit for trial on the basis that it was inconceivable that R would receive a sentence of detention for more than 2 years.

The decision is significant because the Judge went on to clarify the procedure under Section 25, whereby the Youth Court should have revisited the issue of venue at the committal proceedings, and were entitled to revert to accepting jurisdiction and dealing with the matter summarily.

The Claimant was represented by Garden Court North Chambers’ Pete Weatherby (instructed by Otten Penna Solicitors).

Chambers news

Chambers news

Rosalind Burgin negotiates compassionate deal to keep single mother of three in her home

Garden Court North’s Rosalind secured a £7,000 rent arrears reduction for her client at the Manchester Civil Justice Centre (pictured). Credit: Marmalade Photos / Shutterstock....

Chambers news

Garden Court North stands in solidarity with Hillsborough victims and families on 36th anniversary

Fans pay tribute to the 97 Hillsborough victims before Liverpool FC’s Premier League match against West Ham United on 13 April, 2025, at Anfield Stadium,...

Chambers news

Charlotte Parry’s death contributed to by neglect on part of Greater Manchester Mental Health trust, inquest jury finds

The jury’s findings brought an end to an emotional two-week inquest at Manchester Coroner’s Court (pictured). Credit: Alex Blair / Garden Court North Chambers.  ...

Chambers news

Alexander McColl successfully secures interim relief in homelessness judicial review

Alexander represented his client (‘M’) at the Administrative Court in the Manchester Civil Justice Centre (pictured). Credit: Marmalade Photos / Shutterstock.   Garden Court North’s...

Sign up to our mailing list

Our mailing list is dedicated to professionals with an interest in our work.

Sign up