Mark George QC Let sleeping dogs lie: Cross-examination in advance of trial in cases of sexual assault

20 Jun 2013

Commenting in a piece on the Justice Gap, Garden Court North Chambers’ Mark George QC expresses his concern over the use of the dormant provision under section 28 of the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999, which allows for the cross examination of witnesses before trial in cases involving sexual assault.

“What is to happen if long after the event the witness says that they wish to give evidence in court? And if the answer is that they will still be able to choose at that stage, then again it raises the question about the point of this whole exercise .”

It must not be forgotten that we have an adversarial system in the UK and that involves witnesses being challenged as to the truth of their testimony. That may be unpleasant for the witness but it is a necessary part of the trial process in order to test the validity of the evidence.”

There is an old adage that advises that we should let sleeping dogs lie. The fact that section 28 has lain unused on the stature book for so long should tell us that many think it is unworkable in practice. Despite that it seems the government is now determined to give it a try. I do not think it will work, certainly not in multi-handed cases and I suspect it will turn out to be far more trouble that ever it was worth .”

The full article is available at The Justice Gap.

Mark George QC is a barrister and Head of Chambers at Garden Court North Chambers.

Share this



The crisis in the Criminal Justice System

Drawing on 40 years' of experience, Garden Court North Chambers' Mark George QC explains why the Criminal Justice System is in crisis.


Mark George QC on why you should consider doing an Amicus internship

If you are human rights lawyer in the making, volunteer to work in a law office in one of the US death penalty states.


The recent disclosure fiascos show the criminal justice system is in deep crisis – why are senior figures denying this simple fact?

Mark George QC, Head of Garden Court North Chambers, explains why the criminal justice system is at crisis point.


Human trafficking – the correct approach to forced domestic labour

Garden Court North Chambers' Lucy Mair discusses R (on the application of NM) v Secretary of State for the Home Department.

Sign up to our mailing list

Our mailing list is dedicated to professionals with an interest in our work.

Sign up