Public inquiry opens into death in prison custody

30 September 2008

A public inquiry opens today into the self-inflicted death of Bernard “Sonny” Lodge who died on 28th February at HMP Manchester in 1998.

Sonny’s family have long been calling for an appropriate inquiry into his death. Following his death, the Prison Service set up an internal investigation into the tragedy. This did not involve the family at all and the report was not disclosed to them or published in any form.

In 2001 the inquest took place in front of HMC Leonard Gorodkin and a jury. It was highly controversial as the jury were not allowed to return a verdict other than “killed himself”, “accident” or “open”. One juror refused to sign the Form of Inquisition which records the verdict and stormed out of court, and several jurors complained to the news media and family that they had been gagged.

Since the inquest, lawyers representing the family have bought judicial review proceedings asserting that the inquest was not conducted in accordance with the requirements of Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights. After a landmark judgment, the family have been awarded this new inquiry.

The family hope this inquiry will examine:

  • Evidence of victimisation, bullying and assault by prison officers;
  • Evidence of a lack of proper record keeping at two prisons;
  • Failure of prison system to provide information as to self-harm risk to key decision-makers;
  • Failure of prison doctor to check medical records before allowing deceased to be located alone in a punishment cell; and
  • Failures to operate existing suicide prevention policies and failures to take heed of clear warning signs from the family, and from Sonny himself.

The public hearings will examine a number of witnesses. The inquiry is chaired by Ms Barbara Stow, who was formerly an Assistant Prisons and Probation Ombudsman. She will then write a final report which will become a public document.

The family are being represented at the Inquiry by Pete Weatherby of Garden Court North Chambers and Robert Lizar of Robert Lizar Solicitors, Manchester.

Chambers news

Chambers news

Join us!

Due to significant demand across our core practice areas and our programme of strategic growth, Garden Court North Chambers is recruiting across all core practice...

Chambers news

GCN welcomes Rebecca Wright

We are delighted to announce that Rebecca Wright has joined Garden Court North Chambers today. Rebecca is an experienced barrister who will join our Family...

Chambers news

Alexa Thompson and Helen Peden begin their second six

Pupil barristers Alexa Thompson and Helen Peden are now “on their feet” after commencing the practising period of their pupillages this week. Over the past...

Chambers news

Senior members highlight Public Inquiry problems to House of Lords Statutory Inquiries Committee

Pete Weatherby KC and Anna Morris KC have identified four significant problems with Public Inquiry processes. In their written evidence to the House of Lords...

Sign up to our mailing list

Our mailing list is dedicated to professionals with an interest in our work.

Sign up