Rethinking double jeopardy

5 January 2012

David Norris and Gary Dobson were convicted and sentenced for the racist murder of Stephen Lawrence this week. In an article for online magazine The Justice Gap, Garden Court North Chambers’ Mark George QC writes about the change in double jeopardy law which allowed this trial to go ahead.

In his article, Mark looks back to the historical origins of double jeopardy and contrasts the domestic position with that in the United States, “where it was regarded so fundamental that it was enshrined in the Fifth Amendment (‘nor shall any person be subject for the same offense to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb’™)”.

He explains that “the range of cases that can be re-tried as a result of the change in the law is limited…the interests of the accused are protected by the procedures that the prosecution have to initiate”.

Mark George QC is a barrister and Head of Chambers at Garden Court North Chambers.

News

News

Pete Weatherby KC speaks at the Hacked Off and Hillsborough Law Now Rally for Justice

Garden Court North’s Pete Weatherby KC (pictured) addressed the rally in Liverpool on 28 October 2026. Credit: Hacked Off.   Garden Court North’s Pete Weatherby...

News

Multiple missed opportunities to prevent or minimise harm at TEWV hospitals, inquest into death of Emily Moore finds

Garden Court North’s Anna Morris KC led Pragnya Iovine in representing Emily Moore’s family during the three-week inquest.

News

High Court rules Somerset Council’s council tax reduction scheme unlawful in application to disabled resident 

Garden Court North’s Tom Royston and Alexa Thompson have acted for Andy Mitchell throughout his High Court claim.

News

Inquest jury finds “unacceptable delays” by prison officers contributed to Stephanie Brennan’s death at HMP Styal

Garden Court North’s Kate Stone and Pragnya Iovine represented Stephanie’s family and partner during the inquest at Cheshire Coroner’s Court.