Sonia Birdee secures 50% beneficial interest in family home for client in single owner case

25 September 2024

Sonia Birdee

Sonia Birdee represented a Defendant who faced possession proceedings brought under the accelerated procedure. The claim was primarily defended on the basis that she had a 50% beneficial interest in the property, and she also argued that the s21 notice was not valid because the Landlord, her ex-partner, had not provided his name and address on the Gas Safety Certificate.

The Defendant succeeded on both arguments.

The parties began a relationship and moved to the UK to live together. Within 6 months they were engaged and 4 years later had a child together. Shortly after the child was born, a house was purchased by the claimant in his sole name for the family to live together. The Claimant said that he couldn’t put the mortgage in both names because the Defendant was not working at the time and despite promising he would several times after that, he did not subsequently add her to the mortgage.

After the Claimant had an affair and left, he persuaded the Defendant to sign a tenancy agreement saying she could thereby get benefits and afford to take over the mortgage payments.

A beneficial interest was established on the facts which supported an express common intention between the parties that the property would be shared between herself and her partner. Even if that had not been the case, the Defendant satisfied the court that she had paid over 50% of the loan secured to pay the deposit and had therefore both contributed to the purchase price and acted to her detriment (Oxley v Hiscock[2007] UKHL 17, [2007] 2 AC 432).

The mortgage arrangement was found to support this finding (Eves v Eves[1975] 1 WLR 1338,Grant v Edwards[1986] Ch 638).

The court declared that the Defendant had a 50% beneficial interest on the basis of the loan repayment, contributions to bills over 8 years, housekeeping, childcare and a general mixed approach to finances.

The s21 was invalid because of the failure to provide landlord details on the gas safety certificate (Trecarrell House Limited v Rouncefield[2020] EWCA Civ 760).

Sonia Birdee was instructed by Lisa Craggs at Shelter.

Click the link to read more about Garden Court North’s Housing and Homelessness team.

 

 

Chambers news

Chambers news

Universal Credit rent deductions scheme declared unlawful by High Court

In R (Roberts) v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions [2025] EWHC 51 (Admin) (16 January 2025) the High Court (Fordham J) decides that the...

Chambers news

Amy Butcher: Coroner identifies “muddled and unclear system for the prescription of medication” and issues Prevention of Future Deaths report to the Secretary of State for Health & Social Care

Amy Butcher was 27 years old when she died by suicide. She was under the care of the Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust Crisis...

Chambers news

Child defendant indicted for the attempted murder of her friend is sentenced to a Youth Rehabilitation Order.

Nina Grahame KC represented a 14-year old girl committed to Minshull Street Crown Court for the attempted murder of her 14-year old friend, possession of...

Chambers news

Court of Appeal dismisses Secretary of State’s appeal in Secretary of State for Work and Pensions v Versnick and Jarvis-Wingate [2024] EWCA Civ 1454 (29 November 2024)

This case concerned whether an EU national with pre-settled status could rely on benefits paid to his wife, a British citizen, to be entitled to...

Sign up to our mailing list

Our mailing list is dedicated to professionals with an interest in our work.

Sign up