Garden Court North Chambers
Garden Court North Chambers
T: 0161 817 6377 E: gcn@gcnchambers.co.uk

Exceptional cases funding granted for first time in welfare rights case

5 December 2014

In Secretary of State for Work and Pensions v PD CE/783/2014, Upper Tribunal (AAC), ‘exceptional cases funding’ was granted by the Legal Aid Agency  for what appears to have been the first time in a welfare rights case.

The case was the Secretary of State’s appeal against a FTT decision which found that the regulations designed to migrate claimants from Incapacity Benefit to ESA are ultra vires. It was heard by a three-judge panel in November and judgment is awaited.

In arguing successfully that the refusal of funding would breach PD’s Art 6 ECHR rights, PD relied on comments made in JC v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions (ESA) [2014] UKUT 352 (AAC), §§62-63, which arguably demonstrate that ‘exceptional cases’ funding should be routine in three-judge panel cases.

Tom Royston acted for the benefit claimants in both PD and JC, instructed by the Child Poverty Action Group and Kirklees Law Centre respectively.

Chambers news

The legal challenge was brought by two women, represented by Garden Court North's Tom Royston, in the Court of Appeal (pictured) in London. Credit: Lazy Llama / Shutterstock.

Chambers news

Court of Appeal gives mothers permission to appeal High Court decision on two-child limit ‘rape clause’

The Court of Appeal has granted permission to appeal a High Court decision on the exceptions to the 'two-child limit' in universal credit.

Wreaths and tributes to the 97 at the Hillsborough Memorial outside Anfield Stadium in Liverpool. Credit: Alex Blair / Garden Court North Chambers.

Chambers news

A Duty of Candour, Duty to Assist, and Legal Funding for Bereaved Families: Hillsborough Law to be presented in Parliament

Nearly nine years after it was first read in Parliament, the Government is today presenting a Bill fit to be called a ‘Hillsborough Law'.

Garden Court North's Pete Weatherby KC and Christian Weaver represent the three adult survivors and Prestfield High School, respectively. Credit: Andrew Brown / Stand Up For Southport.

Chambers news

Southport Inquiry impact hearings begin

Garden Court North's Pete Weatherby KC and Christian Weaver represent the three adult survivors and Prestfield High School, respectively.

Rosalind and Misha represented their client at Liverpool Civil and Family Court (pictured). Credit: Richard Oldroyd / Shutterstock.

Chambers news

Rosalind Burgin and Misha Nayak-Oliver secure settlement for family of four to remain in home

The possession proceedings brought against a family of four concluded at a hearing on Tuesday (26 August) at Liverpool County Court.

Sign up to our mailing list

Our mailing list is dedicated to professionals with an interest in our work.

Sign up