Garden Court North Chambers
Garden Court North Chambers
T: 0161 817 6377 E: gcn@gcnchambers.co.uk

Exceptional cases funding granted for first time in welfare rights case

5 December 2014

In Secretary of State for Work and Pensions v PD CE/783/2014, Upper Tribunal (AAC), ‘exceptional cases funding’ was granted by the Legal Aid Agency  for what appears to have been the first time in a welfare rights case.

The case was the Secretary of State’s appeal against a FTT decision which found that the regulations designed to migrate claimants from Incapacity Benefit to ESA are ultra vires. It was heard by a three-judge panel in November and judgment is awaited.

In arguing successfully that the refusal of funding would breach PD’s Art 6 ECHR rights, PD relied on comments made in JC v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions (ESA) [2014] UKUT 352 (AAC), §§62-63, which arguably demonstrate that ‘exceptional cases’ funding should be routine in three-judge panel cases.

Tom Royston acted for the benefit claimants in both PD and JC, instructed by the Child Poverty Action Group and Kirklees Law Centre respectively.

News

Garden Court North's Mira Hammad represented Palestine Action protester Leona Kamio during the trial. Credit: Pete Speller / Shutterstock.

News

Palestine Action protesters cleared of aggravated burglary

Garden Court North's Mira Hammad successfully represented Palestine Action protester Leona Kamio during the trial.

Garden Court North's Alexa Thompson represented the prisoner at the public hearing in front of the Parole Board, headquartered at 10 South Colonade, London. Credit: Lubo Ivanko / Shutterstock.

News

Parole Board holds first public parole review hearing for prisoner convicted of a terrorism offence

Garden Court North's Alexa Thompson represented the prisoner at the public hearing in front of the Parole Board.

Garden Court North's Tom Royston and Alexa Thompson represented the Claimant in the High Court (pictured). Credit: Lazy Llama / Shutterstock.

News

High Court grants judicial review for disabled Somerset resident to challenge council tax reduction scheme

Garden Court North's Tom Royston and Alexa Thompson represented the Claimant in his challenge to Somerset Council’s tax reduction scheme.

Garden Court North’s Nina Grahame KC will join barristers at a Parliamentary Lobby Day at Westminster on 3 February to discuss the proposed jury reforms. Credit: HY-DP / Shutterstock.

News

Garden Court North’s crime team: Government’s ill-considered proposals to limit jury trials will result in irrevocable damage for no tangible gain

Garden Court North's crime team unequivocally opposes the Government’s proposal to restrict the right to a jury trial.

Sign up to our mailing list

Our mailing list is dedicated to professionals with an interest in our work.

Sign up