Multiple missed opportunities to prevent or minimise harm at TEWV hospitals, inquest into death of Emily Moore finds

18 November 2026

Garden Court North’s Anna Morris KC led Pragnya Iovine in representing Emily’s family during the three-week inquest at Crook Civic Centre. Credit: Richard Coomber / Shutterstock.

Garden Court North’s Anna Morris KC led Pragnya Iovine in representing Emily’s family during the three-week inquest at Crook Civic Centre. Credit: Richard Coomber / Shutterstock.

 

A three-week inquest into the death of Emily Moore has identified multiple missed opportunities to prevent or minimise harm during her treatment at two hospitals operated by the Tees, Esk and Wear Valleys NHS Foundation Trust (TEWV).

Days after her 18th birthday in February 2020, Emily tragically took her own life at Lanchester Road Hospital in Durham.

Jurors found that failings by TEWV was a contributing factor to Emily’s death, including the “chaotic and unsafe” mental health care she received at West Lane Hospital’s Newberry Centre, in Middlesborough.

The inquest also heard that Emily began experiencing severe mental health problems in 2017, aged 15. She was admitted to the Newberry Centre in January 2018, and was later diagnosed with emerging emotionally unstable personality disorder (EUPD).

Garden Court North’s Anna Morris KC and Pragnya Iovine represented Emily’s family during the inquest, which looked at her second admission to the Newberry Centre in March 2019, her transfer to the Psychiatric Intensive Care Unit and Stephenson Ward in Ferndene, Prudhoe, in July 2019, and finally her transfer to Lanchester Road Hospital’s Tunstall Ward for adults in February 2020.

 

The TEWV Inquiry

The Trust has faced strong scrutiny amid the tragic deaths of two other teenage patients, Nadia Sharif and Christie Harnett, which prompted the CQC to close down West Lane Hospital as a matter of urgency in August 2019.

Garden Court North's Anna Morris KC (pictured) addresses a public meeting on 21 January following the announcement of the TEWV Inquiry. Credit: Ison Harrison.
Garden Court North’s Anna Morris KC (pictured) addresses a public meeting on 21 January following the announcement of the TEWV Inquiry. Credit: Ison Harrison.

 

The inquests into both girls’ deaths were suspended on 15 July 2026, during Emily’s inquest, following the announcement of a public inquiry into the TEWV Trust.

Anna and Ciara Bartlam are instructed by Ison Harrison to represent the bereaved families throughout the inquiry.

 

CQC finds “serious concerns” at West Lane Hospital

At the start of the inquest, TEWV accepted a number of failings in relation to Emily’s care. Among the accepted findings was that “patients were not safe and were at high risk of avoidable harm at West Lane Hospital”, according to an inspection report by the Care Quality Commission (CQC) which rated the TEWV Trust’s child and adolescent mental health wards as “inadequate”.

It also stated that “patients’ individual risk assessments and intervention plans at West Lane Hospital did not always accurately reflect the level of patient risk”, and that “staff did not adequately assess, monitor or manage risks to patients and opportunities to prevent or minimise harm were missed”.

Emily’s father David Moore told the inquest that he had repeatedly voiced complaints about the standard of care in the Newberry Centre.

He described the unit as a “hell-hole”, claiming that staff neglected their duties in caring for patients and called Emily insulting names. He also alleged that Emily self-harmed on numerous occasions while under one-to-one supervision.

 

An “unusual and concerning” transition from child to adult mental health services

David described the difference as “chalk and cheese” in Emily’s treatment at the TEWV-operated Newberry Centre compared to the Stephenson Ward in Ferndene, a specialist adolescent unit run by Cumbria, Northumberland, Tyne and Wear NHS Foundation Trust (CNTW).

Consultant psychiatrist Dr Cathlene Seller told jurors that Emily arrived at Ferndene in July 2019 “very, very depressed”, but over the following months became “happy” and “normal”. Incidents of self-harm reduced in both frequency and severity.

Dr Seller said the structured routine at Ferndene, including education and clear daily timetables, had a positive impact on Emily, while consistent restrictions to prevent self-harm helped her feel safe because she knew staff cared about her wellbeing.

Lanchester Road Hospital, Durham (pictured). Credit: NHS.
Lanchester Road Hospital, Durham (pictured). Credit: NHS.

 

Despite these signs of improvement and Emily’s family wanting her to remain under CNTW’s care, there were no adult beds available to her because she was an ‘out-of-area’ patient. The decision was taken to transfer her to Lanchester Road Hospital’s Tunstall Ward, run by TEWV, on 6 February 2020.

Preparation and handover for Emily’s transfer from a Child and Adolescent Mental Health Service (CAMHS) to an adult mental health service was hurried and undertaken at short notice. The jurors heard evidence that her transfer to an adult ward was due to her turning 18, rather than clinical need. Consultant psychiatrist Dr Eman Arebi told the inquest that she and her colleagues had been “concerned” after being told of the admission only a week beforehand – without the joint planning or consultation that would normally take place for patients with EUPD who rely heavily on stable therapeutic relationships .

Emily’s transfer to Tunstall Ward represented a significant change in her care environment. She moved from a five-bed CAMHS ward to a twenty-bed adult ward. Unlike her previous placement, Tunstall did not provide the same level of structured daily activity. Astonishingly, Emily was placed in a room with a known ligature risk, yet this risk was not addressed anywhere in her care plan.

 

Jurors’ findings

On 13 February 2020, the day of Emily’s death, David contacted the Tunstall Ward by phone to raise his concerns about her wellbeing. He had seen a Facebook post by Emily marking what would have been the 18th birthday of a friend who had died while they were both patients at West Lane Hospital, which ended with the words “until we meet again”.

Jurors heard that Emily had previously spoken about feeling guilty over her friend’s death, which clinicians told the jury could have acted as a potential trigger for self-harm. Despite this, the staff member who spoke to David did not record his concerns in her clinical notes.

After 16 hours of deliberation, jurors returned a narrative conclusion which identified numerous factors that contributed to Emily’s death, including:

  • Emily’s ill health and EUPD
  • Her “treatment and trauma throughout interactions and admissions within mental health services”
  • The “everlasting impact” of losing her support network, including the death of a close friend
  • Deviations from agreed treatment plans
  • Being left to ruminate on the day of her fatal injury
  • Failure to address self-harm risks in West Lane patient rooms
  • Lack of oversight of the risks of former West Lane patients who were approaching adulthood

In response to the inquest’s findings, TEWV released a statement saying it “would like to apologise unreservedly for the unacceptable failings in the care of Emily”.

 

Anna and Prag were instructed to represent Emily’s family by Alistair Smith of Ison Harrison Solicitors.

Journalists should refer to the Samaritans Media Guidelines for reporting suicide and self-harm and guidance for reporting on inquests.

 

Additional media

Ison Harrison – Emily Moore Inquest [Rolling Coverage]

Care Quality Commission – Serious concerns at West Lane Hospital CAMHS wards

BBC News – Teen’s traumatic treatment contributed to death

 

For further information, please contact Alex Blair, Communications Manager at Garden Court North Chambers: ablair@gcnchambers.co.uk

News

News

Multiple missed opportunities to prevent or minimise harm at TEWV hospitals, inquest into death of Emily Moore finds

Garden Court North’s Anna Morris KC led Pragnya Iovine in representing Emily Moore’s family during the three-week inquest.

News

High Court rules Somerset Council’s council tax reduction scheme unlawful in application to disabled resident 

Garden Court North’s Tom Royston and Alexa Thompson have acted for Andy Mitchell throughout his High Court claim.

News

Inquest jury finds “unacceptable delays” by prison officers contributed to Stephanie Brennan’s death at HMP Styal

Garden Court North’s Kate Stone and Pragnya Iovine represented Stephanie’s family and partner during the inquest at Cheshire Coroner’s Court.

News

Campaign for Gabe’s Law prompts call for evidence in multi-storey car park safety regulations

Natasha Perry (left) and Johnny Santer (right) are leading the campaign for Gabe’s Law, after both lost sons who fell from multi-storey car parks. Credit:...